In 1963, McTaggart picked up his fourth ABA title, then in 1964 he fought at the Tokyo Olympics and by doing so made history as the first (and currently), only Brit to punch his way through three Olympic games. Unfortunately, McTaggart lost in the second round to Jerzy Kulej of Poland, who went on to win gold.
McTaggart’s 634th fight of his career, was against Larry O’Connell on 30 April 1965, at the Wembley Arena, for the light welterweight ABA title, which McTaggart won on points. O’Connell, best known for his refereeing accolades, was a decorated amateur, having fought over 150 times and was denied ABA titles on two occasions, due to locking horns with McTaggart. Albeit, he did beat the Scot in a non-title contest.
Good friend, fellow Scot and former amateur boxing champion, Ray Caulfield recalled a warming anecdote about McTaggart’s swansong. "His great British rival was Larry O’Connell. When they fought for the ABA Title in 1965, Larry backed Dick into a corner and thought, ‘I have got you right where I want you,’ and he threw a right hand and hit the post. To make matters worse, Dick tapped him on the shoulder and in front of 10,000 people in Wembley said 'I am over here Larry,' and Larry told me that story!" By beating O’Connell, McTaggart was further cemented into the history books, by equalling Fred Mallin’s record of winning five ABA titles.
Following the O’Connell fight, McTaggart retired at the age of 30 with good justification. "It got to the stage where I’d done everything I wanted to achieve in boxing, but I was also struggling with injuries - so, I decided to call it a day. But you know what? I still miss it. I might have to make a comeback!"
Despite only earning £8 as a labourer, the lure of the bright lights and bigger pay packets from the likes of promoters such as Peter Keenan and Jack Solomons, didn’t attract McTaggart. Here’s why. "I was asked a good few times. Each time they’d offer me money in my hand, but I wouldn’t have done it because I just enjoyed boxing. Once you turn pro, it’s not a sport anymore, it’s a living, and I didn’t fancy doing that."